D. decision rule alone on pure-noise evidence (1500 trials of 60 s): antisymmetry and share of P > 0.5 by position rule antisym_err 0-5 s 5-30 s 30-60 s HMM 0.998 8.88e-16 0.488 0.509 0.491 B1 m20 k0.6 1.81e-14 0.485 0.493 0.499 B1 m10 k0.6 1.18e-14 0.498 0.498 0.501 B1 m5 k1.5 4.22e-15 0.508 0.503 0.5 D. OK B. column swap (streams exchanged): max |d' + d| / sd(d) and max |P' + P - 1|, sign agreement of d' = -d; 3 trials per dataset rel_evidence post_err sign_agree pipeline decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) 0.00e+00 2.22e-16 1.0000 direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks 0.00e+00 8.88e-16 1.0000 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 0.00e+00 2.22e-16 1.0000 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m20 k0.6 0.00e+00 1.18e-14 1.0000 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m10 k0.6 0.00e+00 9.55e-15 1.0000 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m5 k1.5 0.00e+00 2.89e-15 1.0000 B. column swap: EXACT FLIP (< 1e-3) C1. EEG with the stimuli of another trial: share of steps with d > 0 (column 0 favoured), by position in the trial; mean +- SE over pairs position 0-5 s 5-15 s 15-30 s 30-60 s pipeline pairs decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) mismatched 0.488 0.501 0.499 0.507 matched 0.555 0.568 0.502 0.504 direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks mismatched 0.455 0.474 0.533 0.505 matched 0.484 0.607 0.756 0.607 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 mismatched 0.468 0.494 0.505 0.498 matched 0.532 0.616 0.622 0.555 C1. mismatched stimuli: largest |share - 0.5| = 0.045 -> NO POSITION / COLUMN PRIOR C2. trial without its first 20 s vs the full trial (evidence 30 s after the cut); correlation and sign agreement, 3 trials per dataset corr agree pipeline decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) 0.996 0.970 direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks 0.997 0.983 fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 0.996 0.973 A. lookahead by perturbation (5 datasets x 10 positions x 3 modes) pipeline perturbed tests changed min_s max_s verdict decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: decoder, offline read-out (3.75 s future) EEG 50 50 1.7500 3.7188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m20 k0.6 EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m10 k0.6 EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m5 k1.5 EEG 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | HMM 0.998 EEG 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m20 k0.6 EEG 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m10 k0.6 EEG 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m5 k1.5 EEG 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: B1 filter run backwards in time EEG 50 50 13.9688 47.7188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) stimulus 50 50 0.2500 0.4688 ok direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: decoder, offline read-out (3.75 s future) stimulus 50 50 0.2500 0.4688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m20 k0.6 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m10 k0.6 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m5 k1.5 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | HMM 0.998 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m20 k0.6 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m10 k0.6 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m5 k1.5 stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: B1 filter run backwards in time stimulus 50 50 13.9688 47.7188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) decoder (lookahead_s = 0.5) EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok direct classifier 10 s, 3 blocks EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: decoder, offline read-out (3.75 s future) EEG+stimulus 50 50 1.7500 3.7188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | HMM 0.998 EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m20 k0.6 EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m10 k0.6 EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok fusion a=0.5, DEC_OFFSET=3 (default) | B1 m5 k1.5 EEG+stimulus 50 50 0.7500 0.9688 ok NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | HMM 0.998 EEG+stimulus 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m20 k0.6 EEG+stimulus 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m10 k0.6 EEG+stimulus 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: fusion with DEC_OFFSET=2 (0.25 s too early) | B1 m5 k1.5 EEG+stimulus 50 50 1.0000 1.2188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) NEGATIVE CONTROL: B1 filter run backwards in time EEG+stimulus 50 50 13.9688 47.7188 VIOLATION (> 1 s) A. submission pipelines: ALL WITHIN 1 s (largest lookahead used 0.9688 s); negative controls (EEG perturbed): all flagged SUMMARY: D ok, B ok, C ok, A ok